Thursday, 23 February 2012

Statement on our PAC president Eric Joyce MP

Eric has shown tremendous insight and interest in the internet and digital policy-making and I was therefore thrilled when Eric last summer agreed to be the president of our Policy Advisory Council.

I have come to know Eric well, having worked with him and Pictfor - the Parliamentary ICT Forum - over the last two years on a variety of legislative areas.

I was shocked to hear news of the alleged assault this morning. Eric has in the past invited me and other Open Digital PAC members to numerous events in the Commons, including drinks in the Strangers' Bar at the centre of last night's incident.

On our numerous meetings I've seen nothing but an honest, hard working and passionate MP who genuinely cares for the issues that interest me, Open Digital and internet users in general.

Importantly, Eric has taken great interest in opening up the workings of Parliament, giving a voice and insight to many interested parties.  He has hosted and attended many internet-themed events inside and outside Parliament, such as a Social Media Governance panel I sat on with Eric during Social Media Week.

Again, the news this morning came out of the blue and the allegations levelled against him are totally out of character for the man I know Eric to be.

It's clear Eric now faces a serious accusation. Above reiterating that Open Digital values Eric's input and commitment to digital policy issues there's little else I want to say or do until the police investigation concludes.

James Firth

CEO, Open Digital Policy Organisation

Tuesday, 7 February 2012

Search neutrality at Pictfor, 6th February: did Google abuse its market position? Should we even care?

Search neutrality broadly describes the subject of skewing search engine results to favour one website or category of websites over another.  The skewing can be done by hand, i.e. maintaining lists of sites to favour or penalise, or by tweaking the algorithms that derive search results.

Discussions tend to fall into three brackets:
  • Should search engines "clean up" results to remove infringing or unlawful content? 
  • How can accountants and business owners quantify and mitigate search engine dependency risks for businesses whose income is highly dependent on the secret ranking algorithms of search providers, algorithms subject to change without notice? 
  • Antitrust and whether search engines abuse their role as gatekeepers in order to promote their own goods and services above rivals, and what if anything can be done about this?
Last night's event at Pictfor in the Grand Committee Room at Parliament focussed on the latter - the potential for market abuse - and heard from Shivaun Raff, co-founder and CEO of Foundem, a British vertical search engine (categorised search - a type of price comparison site for any product), security consultant and blogger Alec Muffett and internet veteran entrepreneur Mark Margaretten.

Monday, 6 February 2012

Policing and social media, the Surrey Police App, Digital Surrey 25th January

Below are the videos from January's Digital Surrey, which Open Digital sponsored with the help and support of Surrey Enterprise and the University of Surrey.

Surrey Police have created a mobile phone app to help with neighbourhood policing.  I won't take anything away from Chief Superintendent Gavin Stephens, (@CCuptStephens) and developer Angus Fox (@nuxnix), you can hear them describe the project themselves and answer questions in the videos below.

Thanks very much also to the team at thebluedoor for help with organising and London Corporate Media for kindly donating the videos.


Surrey Police view
 

Developer view
 

Open Digital sponsor's Talk

Thursday, 2 February 2012

Identonomics - the economics of online identity, part 1: personal data is the currency

Skip to: [part 2] [part 3]

Facebook's IPO reveals the value of online audience today. Each registered user is worth on average $4.38 per year in revenue, or $1.18 in profit.  The business is hugely profitable, making $1bn profit from $3.7bn revenue.

483m people use Facebook every day, and we know from previous data released that Facebook gets around 100 billion hits a day.  Together these stats give a very rough idea of the very low revenue per page impression and per daily unique user it receives. Around 2 cents revenue per active user per day; or, about a dollar from every 10,000 hits.

It's worth noting that not one cent of this income comes from Facebook's core users. Its services are free at the point of access.

But its users are paying in one way or another. EU Commissioner Viviane Reding said in a speech last Wednesday (25th January, video here):
“Personal data is the currency of today’s digital market”
On one hand, Reding is wrong; for ad-funded services free at the point of access, the value is in the audience and participation is the currency.

But on the other hand she's spot on, as our "spending decisions" when choosing how to use free online services must be based on how much we are prepared to reveal about ourselves.

Personal data must start to be seen as a currency - if there is to be any hope of market forces conspiring in the public interest rather than the interest of advertisers.

Tuesday, 31 January 2012

Help fund a policy organisation

I never thought it would be easy and I knew I didn't have all the answers.

The challenge is to find ways to fund the kind of research and advocacy we're doing here at Open Digital without becoming enslaved by any single person or organisation.

If you can help in any way, by:
  • Spreading the word
  • Employing the services of our consulting arm, Open Digital Consulting (bound by charter to donate at least 50% of its profits to the policy organisation)
  • Becoming a donor, shareholder or both
 Please get in touch: support@opendigital.org or see more information on our Standardised Personal Data License project.

The funding conundrum

As I said at last Wednesday's Digital Surrey, as an organisation we must avoid some of the pitfalls of other groups working on digital policy.

Read more about some of the pitfalls of policy funding here.

Data ethics - why should your business care?

What's in it for your business, when much of our work seems to be focussed on public interest?

Because I firmly believe public concern must be embraced by any digital business aiming for sustainability.

The long term interest of any sustainable business is closely aligned with the interests of its consumers. It's as simple as that.

If you want to make money from the processing of, and trade in, data about individuals you will benefit from the trust and support of those individuals.

Acting in a highly ethical manner is the key to gaining trust, and even ethical businesses need help and support convincing the world of their ethical credentials.  If your business aims to do more than make a quick buck it needs to take proactive steps towards understanding the issues.

Our organisation's own plan for long term sustainability

My plan is to make Open Digital a sustainable self-funding organisation, but it will take time to get to this stage, and therefore we need cash help getting there.

I believe the organisational structure will then promote policy research in the public interest through semi-independent oversight of the policy organisation by our Policy Advisory Council (PAC).

Our structure also minimises the impact of cash dependency.  Our founding charter guarantees the policy organisation will receive 50% of the profits from the consulting business, and the PAC gets to decide how this is spent.

Open Digital -  structured to promote community interest
But my plan requires Open Digital Consulting to be profitable, and that won't happen overnight.  Hence my decision not to launch as a non-profit, but to offer shareholders willing to stand by the whole organisation a chance to share in the long term profits.

The first 9 months

For a fledgling policy organisation with only very weak connections to the political scene we've had an amazing start.  I attended ministerial meetings with Communications Minister Ed Vaizey to discuss web blocking, plus a 5-minute interview on Sky News' Jeff Randall Live on the same subject.

Our first report (pdf) was referenced in print on page 2 of the Financial Times and has been cited in numerous other reports.  I've been quoted on privacy, security and copyright issues in most major computer magazines.

I'm also told that our paper arguing against the government's plans for a Public Data Corporation (pdf) helped persuade decision makers inside the Cabinet Office to shelve the plans, opting instead for a more open approach to public data.

Aims and forthcoming projects


(More information on our Standardised Personal Data License project)

Our long term goal is to improve trust in digital products and services for the benefit of all; we believe this can be done whilst maintaining the principle of a free and open internet through fair market competition.

One of the barriers to trust we have identified is clarity and transparency over what data about us is being gathered and how that data is being used and traded.

Only through clarity and understanding can consumers make informed choices about what level of personal information to share with any given service.

If personal data is the new digital currency, a catchphrase many are using, we currently have a confusopoly in the market place.

In a confusopoly, the "price" of using the service is transparent, but too confusing for consumers to understand.  Therefore consumers make bad choices, and less than ethical businesses are able to profiteer.

A project we hope to launch over summer aims to iconify privacy, bringing clarity to users to help cut through the confusopoly.  It's been tried before, but that is not going to stop us:


Note, the icons pictured are just examples. We want to rank privacy on a simple scale of 1-6, maybe adding additional information to distinguish between passive tracking and active data gathering.

The final icon design will be decided through a community project, and that itself introduces a challenge of ownership in the end result. We need intellectual property in the icons to prevent misuse, but the community needs to see that Open Digital will never profit unduly from a community project.

We therefore propose to hold the intellectual property in the icons in trust.

So...

If you run a business or are a reasonably wealthy individual with an interest in privacy, trust or digital policy, please consider becoming a donor-shareholder.

Significant shareholders get a seat at the table of our truly unique organisation, and a chance to share in half the profits if we achieve our aims.

Alternatively, if your business wants insight or training on any digital policy area, please consider using the services of Open Digital Consulting.  Part of our fee will go towards supporting our policy work.

And above all, if you like what we're doing, please spread the word and get involved.  Tell us about your concerns. Email contact@opendigital.org or engage with us on Twitter: @open_digital.

The funding conundrum

Funding a policy organisation in a way which provides reasonable independence and allows fair reward for those researching policy areas is the most significant challenge Open Digital faces.

Some think tanks stand accused of becoming enslaved to their backers, afraid to stray into policy areas their backers find uncomfortable; and, occasionally, promoting the vested interests of their backers.

Sponsored reports inevitably lead to research and advocacy following the money. And because incumbents have the most cash to spend, the policy areas incumbents want examined get examined. But who stands up for the innovators, emerging businesses and the public?

Academic organisations generally act with independence, but are often slow off the mark for analysis and research into rapidly evolving technology.

Civil society groups also play an independent role; but, reliant on public donations, its necessary for such groups to create a certain level of noise in order to maintain support, and sometimes the message gets lost in the noise.

And for an organisation attempting to influence public policy, it is simply wrong for us to charge for access to reports and white papers.  Research which affects public policy must be open to public scrutiny, it's as simple as that.

Read about our funding plans here.

Thursday, 26 January 2012

Polarised debate over EU data protection must be a wake up call for big data corps, they can't have it both ways

There are deep and complex issues to be discussed regarding EU plans for an overhaul of data protection regulation.  Whilst I don't want to rush to judgement on the detail, one thing is clear from the BBC's technology correspondent Rory Cellan-Jones' blog - it's really put the wind up Google:
A senior executive at the search firm told me that two industries which depended on data, advertising and the web, were just about the only things a sclerotic European economy had going for it, and now both were in danger of being strangled by bureaucracy. 
"The data protection directive sees data as a bad thing," said the executive
Whilst many see the combative approach of EU commissioner Viviane Reding and her equally bullish partner-in-crime-come-potential-adversary "Steelie" Neelie Kroes as a good thing - a positive part of a fight for control over our data as the only language the big data corporations understand is the law - I have some sympathy for Google's apparent frustration.

I don't believe confrontation leads to good law, and by good I mean law which is effective in its aim, proportionate in scope and is not overburdensome to enforce - enforcement burden: level of policing required, economic cost of red tape and infringement on personal freedom/autonomy.

Part of my criticism of digital intellectual property enforcement legislation (SOPA, PIPA, ACTA and DEA) is the way these laws were conceived and drafted; in a confrontational environment.  All attempt, in varying degrees, to regulate an industry - the internet industry - without extensive consultation with the industry they're trying to regulate.

In fact in many cases the internet industry was deliberately excluded from the process, in other cases public consultations were carried out only to ignore serious objections from credible voices within the industry.

The internet, its relationship with society and with commerce is incredibly complex in nature. In no other complex industry would governments attempt to regulate without extensive consultation with the industry (e.g. banking, medicine).  Concerns about regulatory capture noted, it is equally unacceptable to completely exclude from the discussion those with the best insight and understanding of the problem the regulation attempts to solve.

UPDATE 12:53: note I said "exclude from the discussion." Granted companies can lobby and respond to consultations, but I see opportunity for meaningful and constructive dialogue between all stakeholders. Only through such dialogue can we hope to achieve a better understanding of the problem, and only then can laws be drafted to solve the problem. The process as it stands is confrontational.

Data protection and digital privacy are serious legitimate issues of public concern.  But unless legislation is workable one of three things will happen.

Either regulation will be ignored and eventually abandoned due to enforcement burden; or, data companies will exit the EU yet continue to collect/process/sell data on EU citizens due to the elastic nature of the online jurisdiction - and still turn a profit without an EU presence, robbing EU states of any economic benefit; or, EU businesses and citizens will be denied the benefit of technological advances and low-cost services because of the effective outlawing of certain data practices.

Yes we need to do something as a society to address legitimate concerns, but I personally feel that something has to acknowledge both the scale of the problem and the limited impact legislation can have.

Does the EU data protection regime "see data as a bad thing?"

I believe we need to radically rethink our approach to digital privacy and data protection.  The harm spectrum is broad and our current understanding narrow, with a lot of grey in the middle.

We need to separate the two concepts of personal data and privacy. They are fundamentally different. We need to work with the internet industry as a whole to draw the boundaries on privacy to prevent intrusive monitoring of what are clearly private actions.

But there is a possibility we need to scale-back our data protection demands in some areas when it relates to data captured in the online equivalent of a public space.

Yet my sympathy for Google and other technology giants is tempered by their unwillingness to date to engage with privacy advocates and fund a broad cross-section of community-led policy research.

Yes there is self interest, because Open Digital needs financial support to reach our self-funding goal (see slide 9 from my presentation at Digital Surrey last night), but I hear this from many advocates involved in the digital privacy debate: only this morning I saw, from Privacy International advisory board member Alexander Hanff:
I'm about as happy with a state-driven approach to privacy as I am with a corporate free-for-all. At the heart of the debate is an issue that affects everyone, globally, whether or not they have access to the internet - because the ramifications for global trade and societies around the world if we get this wrong are enormous.

Any sustainable business must see that a key part of sustainability is building trust with its customers, and that relationship is the focus of our research into digital privacy (see slide 7 from my presentation at Digital Surrey last night).

Big corporations can't have it both ways, they must either support independent initiatives to understand the problem with the aim of coming to a broad consensus on what data protection legislation is needed, or risk bad laws stemming from a frustration with the way a fledgling personal data industry has behaved so far.