Showing posts with label Privacy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Privacy. Show all posts

Monday, 19 March 2012

Belfast 2012: privacy initiatives as an enabler for cyber security

I was lucky to get an invite to the CSIT 2012 cyber security summit.

Credit to the CSIT team in Belfast for creating a unique atmosphere which got the balance absolutely right - not too academic for industry to feel excluded, government participation without the grandstanding or justification sometimes seen, and plenty of opportunity for detailed open discussion amongst global delegates from industry, academia and government.

I attended for three reasons. Firstly, I spent the first 8 years of my software career designing secure communications (a patent from back when I worked at Motorola).

Secondly, I want to advocate against locking-down aspects of the internet in the name of security because I passionately believe open societies are stronger societies, and this applies equally to cyberspace.

And finally I wanted to discuss our work on privacy as an enabler to cyber security.

When each of us act with a high degree of autonomy, taking responsibility for our own personal data and protecting our own systems due to our inherent desire for privacy, I believe our networks as a whole will be more secure than if we defer to governments as our primary cyber defender.

This was a recurring theme throughout discussions.

There is what was referred to as an asymmetry in human resources faced by those tasked with securing our networks: relatively small numbers of professionals with varying skill levels facing off against legions of online activists and cyber criminals with an impressive skill set and access to most of the same tools (or 'weapons') as governments.

It went unsaid but one can only assume some nation states have also their own legions.

In a democracy we should be able to rely on citizens to augment the work of government in securing our networks, but for this to happen we need both mutual trust between citizens and government security agencies, and for citizens to feel motivated and able to help.

Specifically on privacy there are additional reasons why privacy can be an enabler to cyber security.

All sections of society are vulnerable to data loss through their ordinary everyday use of the internet.  Lack of data privacy can become a national security risk when personal data of those in sensitive positions becomes accessible to those with hostile intent, who may use private information to extort or to blackmail.

Whilst traditionally privacy has been seen in some quarters as at odds with security and policing requirements - e.g. the use of network monitoring tools to spot threats and investigate crime - there's also an argument against this.

In some cases a focus on intrusive policing and intelligence-gathering techniques can come at the expense of developing more sustainable community-based policing models for cyberspace.

Information technology is still developing apace, therefore capability-based policing - a reliance on a power available only to police and security forces such as network monitoring, data seizure etc - will for a while at least remain a costly arms race.

Soon after each capability is installed in our networks either technology evolves, requiring further upgrades, or the bad guys up their game leaving the capability obsolete, or both.

A worse scenario exists: the capability might be exploited by the bad guys.

Take the data retention directive, the EU law (which as far as I can establish the UK lobbied for) compels ISPs to store information which might be useful to law enforcement for a period of 6 months to 2 years.

All this potentially exploitable data sitting around in huge silos at ISPs. A capability that is also clearly vulnerable to exploit, especially given the security of such data is in the hands of private companies.

Employees have in the past looked up private data from company databases and sold this information to private detectives working for divorce lawyers, journalists and criminals.

It's not a straight choice between privacy and security. It's a balance between privacy as an enabler to creating a more secure information culture and privacy-invasive policing as a tool to detect and prevent cyber crime.

UPDATE: also, one must not overlook the importance of public trust and the benefits of consensual policing. Invasive monitoring can cause mistrust between the public and security services.

Public trust and confidence in the work of the security forces is a bigger asset, even, than the ability to monitor all electronic communications. A consensual approach makes society stronger and inherently stable.

Tuesday, 13 March 2012

Identonomics part 3: clarity in privacy and the need for a set of standardised personal data licenses

Exploring the economics of online identity

Skip to: [part 1] [part 2] [part 3] [part 4]

In part 1 of this series I propose that the open market in personal data will work ultimately in the interests of advertisers and those buying personal information - not the general public whose data is being used - unless members of the public exert pressure by shunning intrusive data services and selecting private alternatives.

In part 2 I look at some of the reasons regulation in this area may fail to protect consumers whilst risking a negative impact on innovation.

If personal data is the new currency as suggested by European Commissioner Reding , the consumer market is a classic confusopoly: a competitive market that is unable to function in the interests of consumers due to confused pricing.  ‘Buyers’ are unable to choose the ‘cheapest’ alternative and, as a direct consequence, ‘profiteering’ goes unchecked.

With enforcement hampered by the ubiquity and massively distributed nature of data, not to mention the trans-jurisdictional element, many companies are holding on to more and more information about us.

So I'm saying the market if left unchecked will fail to protect consumers, and that may lead to a collapse in trust which will impact innovation. As will regulation. We're doomed, right?

Restoring control to the user

Not quite.  One of the identified barriers to consumer choice is confusion, and our proposal for a standardised set of personal data licenses will help to break the confusopoly and temper the personal data land-grab.

Some data corporations today may not see it this way, but it really is in everyone’s interests to restore control to the user, and I'm pleasantly surprised by a number of global tech companies who do understand this.

Tuesday, 28 February 2012

Identonomics part 2: Law and enforcement, conflict and confusion

Exploring the economics of online identity


Skip to: [part 1] [part 2] [part 3] [part 4]


Previously...

In part 1 I explored the concept of personal data as a currency. Personal data has assumed more importance to the online advertising industry in particular than mere audience; data capture has somehow become an essential component in online advertising.

Yet this isn't a fundamental law of the market. There is still value to advertisers in raw audience; after all we still have billboards on the M4.

Online, the market is currently working in the interests of those paying for personal data or data dependent products like advertising; the few handing over cold hard cash.

It's basic economics: the only group making purchasing decisions are advertisers and those who buy personal data, therefore a competitive market will act ultimately in the interests of advertisers, driving up quality of product and driving down price.

But quality of product if today's trend continues will require gathering and sharing even more sensitive data about us, the users of online services.

If the market is to work instead in the interests of the public, the public must start to make their own purchasing decisions. They must chose to use or avoid services based on how their personal data is used and protected.

In many respects personal data is a currency.  It might not be the only currency, we can still choose to pay in pounds or dollars, and in many cases simple participation may be sufficient.

We can build a market which acts in the interests of the end user, but only if users regain control and start to make informed decisions about the currency they hand over.


Law and enforcement, conflict and confusion

Today the public are not in control. They are conflicted and confused.

This is described by some sociologists as cognitive polyphasia: we want privacy but we want the benefits of sharing. We choose to use privacy-invasive services because they bring rewards, despite privacy worries.  And less invasive alternatives seem slow to emerge.

And they're confused by the mechanics of data sharing: what is being shared, with whom, for what purposes; the length of time data is to be retained and who can see or access the data.

So can and should the law play a role in protecting consumers?

Thursday, 2 February 2012

Identonomics - the economics of online identity, part 1: personal data is the currency

Skip to: [part 2] [part 3]

Facebook's IPO reveals the value of online audience today. Each registered user is worth on average $4.38 per year in revenue, or $1.18 in profit.  The business is hugely profitable, making $1bn profit from $3.7bn revenue.

483m people use Facebook every day, and we know from previous data released that Facebook gets around 100 billion hits a day.  Together these stats give a very rough idea of the very low revenue per page impression and per daily unique user it receives. Around 2 cents revenue per active user per day; or, about a dollar from every 10,000 hits.

It's worth noting that not one cent of this income comes from Facebook's core users. Its services are free at the point of access.

But its users are paying in one way or another. EU Commissioner Viviane Reding said in a speech last Wednesday (25th January, video here):
“Personal data is the currency of today’s digital market”
On one hand, Reding is wrong; for ad-funded services free at the point of access, the value is in the audience and participation is the currency.

But on the other hand she's spot on, as our "spending decisions" when choosing how to use free online services must be based on how much we are prepared to reveal about ourselves.

Personal data must start to be seen as a currency - if there is to be any hope of market forces conspiring in the public interest rather than the interest of advertisers.

Thursday, 26 January 2012

Polarised debate over EU data protection must be a wake up call for big data corps, they can't have it both ways

There are deep and complex issues to be discussed regarding EU plans for an overhaul of data protection regulation.  Whilst I don't want to rush to judgement on the detail, one thing is clear from the BBC's technology correspondent Rory Cellan-Jones' blog - it's really put the wind up Google:
A senior executive at the search firm told me that two industries which depended on data, advertising and the web, were just about the only things a sclerotic European economy had going for it, and now both were in danger of being strangled by bureaucracy. 
"The data protection directive sees data as a bad thing," said the executive
Whilst many see the combative approach of EU commissioner Viviane Reding and her equally bullish partner-in-crime-come-potential-adversary "Steelie" Neelie Kroes as a good thing - a positive part of a fight for control over our data as the only language the big data corporations understand is the law - I have some sympathy for Google's apparent frustration.

I don't believe confrontation leads to good law, and by good I mean law which is effective in its aim, proportionate in scope and is not overburdensome to enforce - enforcement burden: level of policing required, economic cost of red tape and infringement on personal freedom/autonomy.

Part of my criticism of digital intellectual property enforcement legislation (SOPA, PIPA, ACTA and DEA) is the way these laws were conceived and drafted; in a confrontational environment.  All attempt, in varying degrees, to regulate an industry - the internet industry - without extensive consultation with the industry they're trying to regulate.

In fact in many cases the internet industry was deliberately excluded from the process, in other cases public consultations were carried out only to ignore serious objections from credible voices within the industry.

The internet, its relationship with society and with commerce is incredibly complex in nature. In no other complex industry would governments attempt to regulate without extensive consultation with the industry (e.g. banking, medicine).  Concerns about regulatory capture noted, it is equally unacceptable to completely exclude from the discussion those with the best insight and understanding of the problem the regulation attempts to solve.

UPDATE 12:53: note I said "exclude from the discussion." Granted companies can lobby and respond to consultations, but I see opportunity for meaningful and constructive dialogue between all stakeholders. Only through such dialogue can we hope to achieve a better understanding of the problem, and only then can laws be drafted to solve the problem. The process as it stands is confrontational.

Data protection and digital privacy are serious legitimate issues of public concern.  But unless legislation is workable one of three things will happen.

Either regulation will be ignored and eventually abandoned due to enforcement burden; or, data companies will exit the EU yet continue to collect/process/sell data on EU citizens due to the elastic nature of the online jurisdiction - and still turn a profit without an EU presence, robbing EU states of any economic benefit; or, EU businesses and citizens will be denied the benefit of technological advances and low-cost services because of the effective outlawing of certain data practices.

Yes we need to do something as a society to address legitimate concerns, but I personally feel that something has to acknowledge both the scale of the problem and the limited impact legislation can have.

Does the EU data protection regime "see data as a bad thing?"

I believe we need to radically rethink our approach to digital privacy and data protection.  The harm spectrum is broad and our current understanding narrow, with a lot of grey in the middle.

We need to separate the two concepts of personal data and privacy. They are fundamentally different. We need to work with the internet industry as a whole to draw the boundaries on privacy to prevent intrusive monitoring of what are clearly private actions.

But there is a possibility we need to scale-back our data protection demands in some areas when it relates to data captured in the online equivalent of a public space.

Yet my sympathy for Google and other technology giants is tempered by their unwillingness to date to engage with privacy advocates and fund a broad cross-section of community-led policy research.

Yes there is self interest, because Open Digital needs financial support to reach our self-funding goal (see slide 9 from my presentation at Digital Surrey last night), but I hear this from many advocates involved in the digital privacy debate: only this morning I saw, from Privacy International advisory board member Alexander Hanff:
I'm about as happy with a state-driven approach to privacy as I am with a corporate free-for-all. At the heart of the debate is an issue that affects everyone, globally, whether or not they have access to the internet - because the ramifications for global trade and societies around the world if we get this wrong are enormous.

Any sustainable business must see that a key part of sustainability is building trust with its customers, and that relationship is the focus of our research into digital privacy (see slide 7 from my presentation at Digital Surrey last night).

Big corporations can't have it both ways, they must either support independent initiatives to understand the problem with the aim of coming to a broad consensus on what data protection legislation is needed, or risk bad laws stemming from a frustration with the way a fledgling personal data industry has behaved so far.

Wednesday, 25 January 2012

O2 sends your phone number to every website you visit, should you be bothered?

In a word, yes; I very much think this matters.

Why? Because at the very least it allows any website operator to capture your telephone number and potentially use it to send you spam texts or marketing calls.

UPDATE 25-Jan 13:29: Twitter user @alanbell_libsol reports the problem as fixed and I can confirm it's fixed for me too.

The problem

We have confirmed that UK mobile phone network O2 sends your mobile phone number to each website you visit.

The O2 problem was reportedly spotted by @lewispeckover and has been a known issue in the security industry for 2 years, see Collin Mulliner's 2010 CanSecWest talk.

We know the issue also affects at least one operator using the O2 network, GiffGaff.

We have also confirmed the phone number is sent even if you connect your computer or tablet to the internet via your phone, ie tethering.  This strongly indicates the phone number is being injected at some point in O2's network.

Personal data?

What can someone do with your mobile phone number? On its own, not a lot.  They can call you out of the blue, or send you junk texts.

But think how many websites you visit know quite a lot about you, such as your real name, your address, your hobbies, likes and interests? I choose not to disclose my phone numbers to social networking sites because I don't want to be contacted by strangers by phone selling me things I might be interested in.

Tuesday, 24 January 2012

Norwegian Data Inspectorate rules use of Google Apps by companies breaches Norweigian law, cites US Patriot Act

Datatilsynet, The Norwegian Data Inspectorate has effectively outlawed many corporate uses of Google Apps within Norway on privacy grounds.

Reports are only just emerging (in Norwegian) that a "Notice of Decision" dated 16th January (pdf, Norwegian) states that Norwegian companies that make use of Google "cloud" services, (known locally nettskyløsning - essentially Google Apps) with its standard terms "violate the law".  

It is unclear at this stage whether the opinion will be challenged in the courts.

The Norwegian authorities cite the US Patriot Act, which gives "U.S. authorities the ability to monitor terrorist suspects without charge or trial" amongst the reasons why a US-led data protection initiative known as US-EU Safe Harbor was insufficient in itself to guarantee compliance with strict Norwegian data protection laws.

Readers are reminded that Norway is not a full member of the EU, but, as a member of the European Economic Area, complies to all relevant EC directives.

The Norwegian ruling comes 18 months after Danish Data Protection Agency reportedly ruled that sensitive personal information could not be stored on Google's cloud platform (Danish) when Odense Municipality planned to use the service to manage student schedules. 

It also comes at a difficult juncture for Google after revelations cloud data was improperly accessed by Google employees in Kenya in order to "boost its own business".

Complaint

The intervention of the Data Inspectorate stems from a complaint "by an individual" against the municipality of Narvik, a relatively small city whose administrative body was the first government agency in Norway to move to Google Apps, according to Digi.no, an Oslo-based tech blog.

The main issues of the complaint seem to relate to:
  • Where in the world data will be stored, including backup copying, and what protection is available in these countries
  • Whom at Google has access to the stored data
  • Whether it is possible for Narvik Municipality to conduct data "safety" audits for the data stored in the Google cloud - essentially what co-operation from Google was required for a satisfactory audit to be conducted
Inspectorate opinion

The ruling relates to the use of Google's email service by the municipality of Narvik, but the principles outlined extend to other Google cloud services.

To summarise, the Inspectorate found Google does not offer terms and conditions that meet Norwegian law, has no mechanism in place to offer local or customised Ts & Cs, plus the Inspectorate did not have access to sufficient technical information to show adequate data protection measures were in place to allow personal data to be exported to countries outside the European Economic Area.

Therefore the use of Google Apps by Norwegian companies (plus, presumably, any foreign-owned company with a Norwegian presence) to process personal data would put those companies in contravention of three sections (13, 15 and 29) of Norway's Personal Data Act 2000.

Tuesday, 20 December 2011

Facebook's new timeline: privacy worries explained - it's all about choice & control (or lack thereof)

Since writing about Facebook Timeline some, having read my earlier post explaining Timeline, have asked me whether there really is a privacy concern, or whether people just need to get used to the fact the information they chose to share is out there.

This is a legitimate challenge.  The question gets to the nub of what privacy in a digital world means to people, and indeed what is meant by sharing, especially when sharing is amongst friends.

A key plank of privacy is providing users with clarity on how their personal stuff will be used, choice, and ease of control over information they choose to publish.

Facebook doesn't bill itself primarily as a publishing platform.  It sells itself as a social network and, as such, encourages candid disclosure amongst friends.  Yet the Facebook timeline makes your digital exhaust - stretching back years - easily visible and searchable without providing all the tools necessary to bulk-manage older posts. 

Privacy concerns about Timeline aren't about public versus "private", the new feature doesn't alter the privacy settings of old posts - although many people are now using tighter privacy settings than they were when they first joined Facebook. 

The issue is, literally, amongst friends.

Most of us have added a lot of new friends over the years.  Old posts were written with a different audience in mind and we perhaps don't want to have e.g. updates from years ago relating to a previous partner flaunted in front of our new love.

Friday, 16 December 2011

Facebook's new timeline - laying out your past, and there's no going back from this privacy minefield

You might want to think very carefully before upgrading to Facebook's new timeline.

It brings additional visibility to older posts, sometimes from many years ago.

No problem, you might think.  But you better be sure, for once users sign up to the new timeline it's a one-way street. Facebook gives you 7 days to manage old posts before they become visible, and we found no way of delaying or stopping this process; but you can, of course, speed it up.

UPDATE: privacy worries explained - it's all about choice & control.

One thread on Facebook's Help Centre has (at the time of writing) 380 responses to a request to turn the feature off, many pleading for an answer.

Timeline "preview" - you have 7 days to sort your past.
On the surface the new feature doesn't sound too problematic. It provides a neat way of scrolling back through a user's older posts. It doesn't alter the privacy settings of those posts, and in some respects the information's already 'out there', so there's no problem, right?

Not quite. The Timeline feature brings your past to the present. Facebook automatically selects a collection of pictures and updates from each year and presents them as "highlights". One click and I'm back to 2007 and a selection of pictures before I got married.

It's up to the user to manage what's shown - if you have the time to do this. Before you know it, your digital exhaust stretching back many years is easily browsable and visible to friends - and possibly everyone, depending on your privacy settings.

Thursday, 15 December 2011

The difference between privacy and "personal data"


It's not what you choose to read, it's where you choose to read it...

Notable from the "privacy" debate around media ethics is the number of times I hear people say, "this information is private" when they actually mean personal.  From judges to MPs, lawyers, celebrities and journalists conflate the two issues.

Privacy is about choice; finding a private space where you're free to act unobserved.  Privacy is critical to personal and social development.

Private spaces are necessary to learn and practice without the threat of humiliation or outside criticism.  Without such spaces our entire lives would be open to outside scrutiny, making life oppressive for all but a lucky outgoing few able to withstand the pressure of constant monitoring.

Private spaces are also incredibly important to the formation of social and family bonds.

"Personal data" is commonly defined in legislation marking out certain classes of information that are deemed to be confidential.  Such classes typically include political views, religion and sexual preference and are specified in laws such as the UK Data Protection Act.


Tuesday, 13 December 2011

The privacy outlook 2011->2012 part 1: key themes

This is part 1 of a 3-part series

After a lot of time looking at the great digital copyright challenge and a brief foray into 4G mobile data, "adult" content blocking and social media injunctions I spent the last week firmly back on digital privacy. A greater challenge even than copyright, and with perhaps greater significance.

Two seminars in 6 days and a lot of meetings and web chats later some key themes are emerging:
  1. The "can't do that because of privacy" argument is losing any sway it once had. Governments now hold aloft useful services reliant on private data that people willingly use - Foursqare, Facebook, Amazon recommends - to attempt to discredit arguments like "it's my data, you can't have it."  Don't shout all at once, I know such a rebuttal is flawed; I'm just explaining the situation as I see it.  As a speaker said at a recent privacy seminar, government policy is not driven by proven fact and rational argument but by the headlines in the Daily Mail.  A valid political argument is one that washes with the public.
     
  2. Enforcement of do's and don'ts through the law is a pipe dream.  Data is everywhere, we have a massively distributed problem; and the problem is relatively knew, technology - and the markets - in many respects needs time to catch up with themselves.  Many data protection laws and regulations are nothing more than best practice - in reality prosecutions are expensive, time consuming and data regulators have relatively low capability, are under-resourced, have limited power and as a consequence are of little deterrent.  (If they had more power there'd be a risk of encroachment into free speech and free press territories!) Regulation needs to aim at a enforcing a few high level principles - setting the red lines on the harm spectrum - and leave the rest to technology and the markets to solve.
     
  3. Privacy is still a debate driven by fear.  Not just the odious McMullen with "privacy is for paedos" (perhaps belying McMullen's own fear of the privacy brigade) but fear by citizens not understanding the privacy implications of their actions, whipped up into a frenzy only when the Daily Mail tells them to be angry; and fear within corporations afraid of a privacy backlash - a rare but devastating event.  Corporations and government officials trying to do the right thing are walking afraid, whilst the general public is at risk of walking blindly into traps, willingly disclosing too much personal data.  Meanwhile private organisations who either don't give a hoot or justify their behaviour using their own moral code continue to make money out of profiling the population.
     
  4. Transparency is crucial.  More crucial perhaps than any other data protection principle, regulation or law.  But companies and governments don't want to be transparent, mainly because of (3) above, but also because of (1) - they don't want to be told they "can't" do something; and, (2) - being transparent about what they're doing makes them an easy target for the under-resourced regulator.
I'll be exploring around these themes in two follow-up posts.

Monday, 28 November 2011

Press abuses and the failure of the Social Contract

The following text will form a short paper on the subject.  Comments will be incorporated where appropriate. 

Undoubtedly a lot - most, in fact - of the press behaviour being uncovered in the ongoing Leveson Inquiry is abhorrent.  Nothing I say below is intended to justify in my attempt to explain and understand.

It's not that many of the practices and methods employed to monitor celebrities' and sports stars' every moves would be unwarranted if, for example, investigating serious corruption in politics or a police force.

Whilst phone and computer hacking are both clearly illegal (I'm yet to decide how I'd feel if a very serious high-level corruption scandal was unearthed using such techniques) I certainly wouldn't be worried if journalists or private investigators tailed contacts in public, or used covert recording, in pursuit of a story of genuine public interest.

However we're not talking about investigating high level corruption; we're talking about singers, writers, footballers and comedians.

Whilst many of the press methods and practices used to keep tabs on celebrities are not illegal, they are clearly unethical and anti-social when applied indiscriminately in search of dirt on, or to deliberately blacken the name of, someone in the public eye.


Forgetting for a moment about the clearly illegal behaviour, the conundrum of press regulation is to keep press behaviour towards the green end of the spectrum without unduly shackling the press.

And, if the press do need shackling, how to we prevent the manacles of regulation being abused by state or corporate interests to hide stories of legitimate public concern?

Essentially, who will be the arbiters of public interest?

This question of how to regulate is irrelevant if we can work out why the Social Contract failed.  Why did it take so long for any other organisation or institution pick up on the antisocial behaviour of the tabloid press and allow public contempt and market forces to act together to moderate it, thereby working to keep the behaviour of the press in the green zone of the Harm Spectrum?

Note: the press abuses scandal was, eventually, uncovered by sections of the press.

Tuesday, 26 July 2011

Will social media background checks be the catalyst for a consumer privacy backlash?

Studies show an overwhelming majority of people are ‘concerned’ about their online privacy [see here (pdf), and here], yet when I talk to technology companies large and small they tell me privacy awareness amongst the general public is patchy at best.

As social media background checks start to result in applicants being rejected for jobs simply because of pictures and comments posted on social websites, could we start to see a crippling privacy backlash that will prevent adoption of useful technology because of public fear and mistrust?

Personal data is a commodity that can be traded for ease of functionality (ie reconnect with old friends, recommendations based on past interests) or for free or discounted services.  Additionally, there's the ability to post views and beliefs in an attempt to influence a wide audience.

There are three equations in play:
privacy vs utility
privacy vs price
privacy vs influence
Anecdotally; and also through adoption rates for social media, and store discount cards which track customers' every purchase; in the UK at least we're a nation happy to trade privacy for utility and price.

Or are we? When I talk to family and friends about blogging - an unmistakably public activity - under my real name; many are surprised, and some offer me hushed advice to be careful.

Friday, 1 July 2011

John Stuart Mill and liberty, regulation and protection of privacy

In a talk in London on 29 July, Eric Schmidt, Executive Chairman of Google, argued against over-regulation. His premise was that yes the advancements that technology brings can bring with it, in the first flush of that technology, problems; however, those problems that public opinion finds important will most often be solved by technology or by a procedural response to it. In other words give time for the system to self-correct - and presumably only if self-correction does not come (especially after some heavy hinting from opinion and also authority) then regulate.

We must accept that defining what aspects of the web and the Internet to regulate by law and what to regulate by self regulation guided by opinion (on the basis that if you do harm to the customer as a business, eventually the customer will do harm to you) is a very difficult conundrum. What seems clear is that over-regulation is not the answer - but what is over- regulation you may ask?

Eric illustrated his point with a simple example: when telephones became commonplace there was a concern from users that switchboard operators could over-hear conversations and intrude on privacy. Of course they could, and it may well have been a reaction to impose laws on this and in so doing limit what actions could then be taken to replace/improve switchboard operation. Instead no laws were created and relatively shortly the electrical switch was invented which solved the problem without the need for new laws.

I am concerned with the issue of privacy with respect to the web - particularly the self-harm that can be incurred by over-sharing using sites and services which appear private, but are not so - see Clarity in Internet Privacy. However, I am also concerned that legislation in this area, particularly different legislation in different jurisdictions, will not help and will in fact hinder as the world wide web effectively becomes fragmented, and the positive benefits of the web get inhibited. Furthermore, undoubtedly legislation that is rushed may well inhibit further beneficial innovation.

It is important therefore to try and improve privacy through exercise of self control guided by public opinion, and through the application of new technology, and give time for this to occur, before rushing to consider legislation.

The well known philosopher John Stuart Mill summed up this issue well in his essay On Liberty:
"All that makes existence valuable to any one, depends on the enforcement of restraints upon the actions of other people. Some rules of conduct, therefore, must be imposed, by law in the first place, and by opinion on many things which are not fit subjects for the operation of law. 
What these rules should be, is the principal question in human affairs; but if we except a few of the most obvious cases, it is one of those which least progress has been made in resolving. 
No two ages, and scarcely any two countries, have decided it alike; and the decision of one age or country is a wonder to another."
Mill goes on to conclude:
"That principle is, that the sole end for which mankind are warranted, individually or collectively in interfering with the liberty of action of any of their number, is self-protection. That the only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilised community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others."
On the basis that the most egregious of privacy ills today is self-harm, it seems to be that awareness is our first step, followed by self-regulation, not governmental regulation.

Thursday, 30 June 2011

Google+ and privacy circles

I've been arguing too few people pay attention to what privacy actually means.  We bandy the word around in all kinds of contexts.

Is data loss a privacy breach, or a breach of trust?  We willingly handed-over our private data to a third party - a data loss is just part of the risk equation, right?

Is a kiss-and-tell a privacy issue, or a disregard of implied confidentiality?

What is absolutely certain is that the web introduces a whole new domain of privacy issues.  Some say the internet changes everything, but at Open Digital we prefer to look at the internet simply as a tool facilitating human interaction; and, as such, the internet just offers a new and efficient medium for channelling some antisocial behaviour patterns.

Almost all online privacy worries boil down to one simple question: what are the likely consequences of my action?

Thursday, 23 June 2011

Privacy, utility and clarity

Ask ten digital policy experts their view on internet privacy and you're highly unlikely to get a consensus. In fact you might not hear the same opinion expressed by any two.

It will take a great deal of time and research to understand the best approach to provide a balanced right to privacy in the age of data ubiquity whilst protecting core democratic values like free speech.

>> Skip straight to the video >>

John Hendel, writing in The Atlantic, forecast a US/Europe split; with Europe heading down the regulation route as it attempts to protect individual privacy - through concepts such as the right to be forgotten; whilst the UN Special Rapporteur Frank La Rue's report on internet freedoms (pdf) clearly favours free speech - as does the US, given the First Amendment right.

A case from 2009 serves as a good example of the general conflict, when a German law firm attempted to get the names of convicted murderers removed from a Wikipedia page.