In a word, yes; I very much think this matters.
Why? Because at the very least it allows any website operator to capture your telephone number and potentially use it to send you spam texts or marketing calls.
UPDATE 25-Jan 13:29: Twitter user @alanbell_libsol reports the problem as fixed and I can confirm it's fixed for me too.
The problem
We have confirmed that UK mobile phone network O2 sends your mobile phone number to each website you visit.
The O2 problem was reportedly spotted by @lewispeckover and has been a known issue in the security industry for 2 years, see Collin Mulliner's 2010 CanSecWest talk.
We know the issue also affects at least one operator using the O2 network, GiffGaff.
We have also confirmed the phone number is sent even if you connect your computer or tablet to the internet via your phone, ie tethering. This strongly indicates the phone number is being injected at some point in O2's network.
Personal data?
What can someone do with your mobile phone number? On its own, not a lot. They can call you out of the blue, or send you junk texts.
But think how many websites you visit know quite a lot about you, such as your real name, your address, your hobbies, likes and interests? I choose not to disclose my phone numbers to social networking sites because I don't want to be contacted by strangers by phone selling me things I might be interested in.
Wednesday, 25 January 2012
Tuesday, 24 January 2012
Norwegian Data Inspectorate rules use of Google Apps by companies breaches Norweigian law, cites US Patriot Act
Datatilsynet, The Norwegian Data Inspectorate has effectively outlawed many corporate uses of Google Apps within Norway on privacy grounds.
The Norwegian ruling comes 18 months after Danish Data Protection Agency reportedly ruled that sensitive personal information could not be stored on Google's cloud platform (Danish) when Odense Municipality planned to use the service to manage student schedules.
The main issues of the complaint seem to relate to:
Reports are only just emerging (in Norwegian) that a "Notice of Decision" dated 16th January (pdf, Norwegian) states that Norwegian companies that make use of Google "cloud" services, (known locally nettskyløsning - essentially Google Apps) with its standard terms "violate the law".
It is unclear at this stage whether the opinion will be challenged in the courts.
The Norwegian authorities cite the US Patriot Act, which gives "U.S. authorities the ability to monitor terrorist suspects without charge or trial" amongst the reasons why a US-led data protection initiative known as US-EU Safe Harbor was insufficient in itself to guarantee compliance with strict Norwegian data protection laws.
Readers are reminded that Norway is not a full member of the EU, but, as a member of the European Economic Area, complies to all relevant EC directives.
Readers are reminded that Norway is not a full member of the EU, but, as a member of the European Economic Area, complies to all relevant EC directives.
The Norwegian ruling comes 18 months after Danish Data Protection Agency reportedly ruled that sensitive personal information could not be stored on Google's cloud platform (Danish) when Odense Municipality planned to use the service to manage student schedules.
It also comes at a difficult juncture for Google after revelations cloud data was improperly accessed by Google employees in Kenya in order to "boost its own business".
Complaint
Complaint
The intervention of the Data Inspectorate stems from a complaint "by an individual" against the municipality of Narvik, a relatively small city whose administrative body was the first government agency in Norway to move to Google Apps, according to Digi.no, an Oslo-based tech blog.
The main issues of the complaint seem to relate to:
- Where in the world data will be stored, including backup copying, and what protection is available in these countries
- Whom at Google has access to the stored data
- Whether it is possible for Narvik Municipality to conduct data "safety" audits for the data stored in the Google cloud - essentially what co-operation from Google was required for a satisfactory audit to be conducted
Inspectorate opinion
The ruling relates to the use of Google's email service by the municipality of Narvik, but the principles outlined extend to other Google cloud services.
To summarise, the Inspectorate found Google does not offer terms and conditions that meet Norwegian law, has no mechanism in place to offer local or customised Ts & Cs, plus the Inspectorate did not have access to sufficient technical information to show adequate data protection measures were in place to allow personal data to be exported to countries outside the European Economic Area.
Therefore the use of Google Apps by Norwegian companies (plus, presumably, any foreign-owned company with a Norwegian presence) to process personal data would put those companies in contravention of three sections (13, 15 and 29) of Norway's Personal Data Act 2000.
Therefore the use of Google Apps by Norwegian companies (plus, presumably, any foreign-owned company with a Norwegian presence) to process personal data would put those companies in contravention of three sections (13, 15 and 29) of Norway's Personal Data Act 2000.
Monday, 23 January 2012
Don't be sucked into supporting a flawed proposition in an artificially polarised copyright debate
The language in the increasingly hostile battle over online copyright infringement resembles that used in the war on terror or the war on drugs:
Also, arguably, neither war has worked. Ioan Grillo, in his book El Narco, documents the shifting power struggle in the battle to control the supply of illicit drugs and the social and economic impact of various enforcement strategies, including the chilling effect on communities demolished as the powerful slog it out.
Absurd as it may seem, I do see parallels with copyright infringement. If the world's most powerful nation struggles to control supply of a clearly dangerous physical product, how the hell do they expect to police worldwide availability of an intangible product with no known health issues?
There's a lot wrong with the approach to copyright enforcement advocated by many major rights-holders.
But now, with what can only be described as a massive escalation in hostilities, there's a real danger moderate rational-thinking people are being sucked into supporting one of two logically and morally flawed positions; pushed into taking sides in an incredibly complex debate, or backing unhelpful and retaliatory actions of questionable legality (on both sides), simply because one side makes more sense than the other.
Madness, since we're not dealing with a binary debate.
"wherever you are around the world, we're going to after you"Alarm bells should be ringing. Drugs and terrorism ruin lives (in a biological sense). There's no comparison to the commercial problem of designing a market intervention suitable for the digital age to protect those who invest in the creative arts.
Also, arguably, neither war has worked. Ioan Grillo, in his book El Narco, documents the shifting power struggle in the battle to control the supply of illicit drugs and the social and economic impact of various enforcement strategies, including the chilling effect on communities demolished as the powerful slog it out.
Absurd as it may seem, I do see parallels with copyright infringement. If the world's most powerful nation struggles to control supply of a clearly dangerous physical product, how the hell do they expect to police worldwide availability of an intangible product with no known health issues?
There's a lot wrong with the approach to copyright enforcement advocated by many major rights-holders.
But now, with what can only be described as a massive escalation in hostilities, there's a real danger moderate rational-thinking people are being sucked into supporting one of two logically and morally flawed positions; pushed into taking sides in an incredibly complex debate, or backing unhelpful and retaliatory actions of questionable legality (on both sides), simply because one side makes more sense than the other.
Madness, since we're not dealing with a binary debate.
Monday, 16 January 2012
Open Digital will join global protest against copyright anti-piracy overreach, Weds 18th Jan
Today our Policy Advisory Council voted unanimously in favour of Open Digital joining a global protest against two US bills to tackle copyright infringement that we feel go too far.
The motion was simply "should we join the protest?" All six members voted in favour.
Here's what I told PAC members when I proposed the blackout:
The motion was simply "should we join the protest?" All six members voted in favour.
Here's what I told PAC members when I proposed the blackout:
Wednesday, 11 January 2012
What happened when a police force commissioned a neighbourhood policing app? Find out on 25th January
Open Digital are proud to sponsor this month's Digital Surrey with a fascinating talk from Surrey Police's Chief Superintendent for Neighbourhoods Gavin Stephens.
Gavin will be introducing the Surrey Police App, currently available for iPhone (and soon to be available for Android) and will be joined by Angus Fox,
Director of social collaboration software firm Multizone who developed the app.
We will hear about the commissioning and deployment of the Surrey Police App, which connects residents to their neighbourhood police teams, as well as a range of topics from government issues to the social impact on neighbourhoods and public concerns such as privacy.
The University of Surrey will be hosting the event with sponsorship from the Open Digital Policy Organisation.
The University of Surrey will be hosting the event with sponsorship from the Open Digital Policy Organisation.
Unfortunately space is limited and previous demand has been considerable. Please let us or the organisers know if you have to drop out for any reason - this also helps Digital Surrey keep such events free to attend.
Monday, 9 January 2012
Lego's augmented reality kiosk - great use for AR without the lag or fiddle factor
This is worth sharing, it's only the third time I've been excited by an application for augmented reality (AR).
Like the other two applications (goggles for emergency services and the Xbox Kinect), the Lego AR kiosk satisfies three main criteria: it serves a purpose, is low on fiddle factor and the AR application operates with minimal lag.
Many other applications fall over on one or all of these hurdles. I find most phone-based AR like Layar slow to initialise, laggy and fiddly to use.
AR applications for desktop tend to lack purpose and have some fiddle involved in setting up a webcam.
The Lego AR kiosk is a great idea and we could see similar kiosks appearing in shops around the world.
(ht @PaulBaldovin)
Like the other two applications (goggles for emergency services and the Xbox Kinect), the Lego AR kiosk satisfies three main criteria: it serves a purpose, is low on fiddle factor and the AR application operates with minimal lag.
Many other applications fall over on one or all of these hurdles. I find most phone-based AR like Layar slow to initialise, laggy and fiddly to use.
AR applications for desktop tend to lack purpose and have some fiddle involved in setting up a webcam.
The Lego AR kiosk is a great idea and we could see similar kiosks appearing in shops around the world.
(ht @PaulBaldovin)
Friday, 6 January 2012
The 2009 failed prosecution by the Met's Obscene Publications Unit for a written fantasy/horror story
Via Twitter I followed the trial of Michael Peacock, acquitted this afternoon in Southwark Crown Court on 6 counts of distributing obscene DVDs under the Obscene Publications Act 1959.
The prosecution was widely condemned by the liberati of Twitter, and the acquittal therefore welcomed as an important victory against state censorship on a moral level.
The prosecution was widely condemned by the liberati of Twitter, and the acquittal therefore welcomed as an important victory against state censorship on a moral level.
But if you sympathise with Peacock, it's worth sparing a though for Darryn Walker and what is probably one of the most important failed UK prosecutions in the history of the internet.
In 2007 Mr Walker published a fantasy/horror story about the torture, mutilation and rape of members of pop group Girls Aloud on a Usenet Newsgroup. (The story remained for at least a year under the alt.sex.stories hierarchy but has, from a precursory check today, since disappeared.)
Shocking and disturbing, sure - but should such fiction be illegal? And when it's hidden in some internet backwater where's the harm?
And, since the story involved selling body parts of the dismembered songstresses on eBay one can only assume the work contained a level of comedy and/or satire.
And, since the story involved selling body parts of the dismembered songstresses on eBay one can only assume the work contained a level of comedy and/or satire.
Soon after publication, an 18-month legal ordeal which saw Darryn lose his civil service job was started by the most unlikely moral guardians of The Daily Star:
"We can reveal that Interpol has been notified to help track down the man behind the bizarre work"The Daily Star claimed Girls Aloud members were being "stalked by a vile internet psycho". Sensationalised in the mainstream gutter press brought the story to a whole new audience.
Daily Star, 26th July 2007
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)