Monday, 5 December 2011

New round of ministerial meetings on digital copyright enforcement partially opened-up

Update: read a report from the meeting here.

Open Digital has been invited to attend a new round of ministerial meetings on digital copyright enforcement, hosted by Ed Vaizey at the Department for Media, Culture and Sport.

This time the attendee list will be wider, bringing representatives from across the industry.  The first meeting is scheduled for this Wednesday, 7th December, and will feature representatives from:
  • Featured Artists Coalition
  • Google
  • EMI Music UK & Ireland
  • BPI (British Phonographic Industries)
  • Publisher's Association
  • Warner Music
  • Music Publisher's Association
  • Yahoo!
  • Ofcom
  • UKIE (UK Interactive Entertainment)
  • ISPA (Internet Service Providers Association)
  • PRS (Performing Rights Society)
  • Talk Talk
  • Open Digital Policy Organisation
  • Open Rights Group
  • Universal Music
  • Beggars Group
  • UK Music
  • Premier League
  • BSkyB
  • MPAA (Motion Picture Association of America)
  • Virgin Media
  • Sony Music
  • IAB (Internet Advertising Bureau)
  • Consumer Focus
  • Officials from the DCMS
We welcome the Minister taking the significant step of widening the invite list for meetings previously held behind closed doors.

Whilst we appreciate there is still some way to go to bring this discussion fully into the public arena - where it ultimately needs to be - both the Open Rights Group and Open Digital made it clear that our attendance was on condition that:
"discussions can be open and on the record" and we "would not want to find that elements of the discussion or papers at the meeting were deemed to be confidential."
A member of Ed Vaizey's office replied:
"Thanks for your emails - I completely understand.
 We look forward to seeing you on the 7th." 
We are therefore in a position to openly report on the meeting, bringing some scrutiny to a closed process.

If the scope of such meetings enters the territory of new legislation we will be the first people to suggest that such meetings be open to full public scrutiny in the form of a parliamentary [draft bill] committee and a public consultation.  Public policy should not be forged in private.

Friday, 2 December 2011

The GCHQ Cyber Challenge: hqDTK7b8K2rvw

UPDATE 11th Dec (11:59!): Solution here on the Open Digital Blog

.We used a few spare hours in the office yesterday and today to have a go at the GCHQ cyber challenge _Can you crack it? 

Using a combination of Linux and Windows machines, a bit of JavaScript knowledge and 25 years' programming experience we got to stage 2 of 3.   We hope to bring you the full low down of how to solve it if we get there, however we don't want to spoil the fun for those still doing it so we won't say anything until the competition closes, bar this: hqDTK7b8K2rvw  - just to prove we got to where we did, when we did!

Hope to have the full explanation for you a week on Monday!

UPDATE 4th Dec: Just cracked it!

Wednesday, 30 November 2011

Fiscal stimulus? £100m of public money for broadband where it's least needed

The following was first posted on slightlyrightofcentre.com:

Yesterday the Chancellor announced £100m of extra money (or at least I assume it's new money) for broadband investment in UK cities.

Of those, Cardiff, Edinburgh, Belfast and London have already been identified. 6 More cities will follow.

Here's a map from July showing areas with best broadband coverage (light grey) and those with the worst (red). The map is from Ofcom, via ISPReview.  (Click to enlarge).


You shouldn't have to ask your old geography teacher to identify the four capitals receiving some of the £100m.

I'll give you a clue, they're all painted grey or light grey, indicating they already have better than 70% availability of "superfast" broadband (roughly faster than 20Mbps actual line speed download, essentially access to BT infinity service).

The red areas have less than 30% availability.  They will share £20m of funding.  Yes, pretty much the rest of rural Britain will share 1/5th of the money set aside for cities.

The business case: tipping the investment equation, or lining BT's pockets?

The reason I'm so angry about yesterday's announcement is that it doesn't, from a policy position, make much sense.  Yes, I understand innovation isn't a zero-sum game.  Spearheads are needed in order to advance; and we all end up benefiting - even the rural notspots.  If all we knew possible was 56kbps dial-up we'd still be left with 56kbps dial-up.

But parts of Britain still are on 56kbps dial-up, and we face a challenge because large telcos don't see a business case for investing in faster broadband outside of the more densely populated towns and cities.

Monday, 28 November 2011

Press abuses and the failure of the Social Contract

The following text will form a short paper on the subject.  Comments will be incorporated where appropriate. 

Undoubtedly a lot - most, in fact - of the press behaviour being uncovered in the ongoing Leveson Inquiry is abhorrent.  Nothing I say below is intended to justify in my attempt to explain and understand.

It's not that many of the practices and methods employed to monitor celebrities' and sports stars' every moves would be unwarranted if, for example, investigating serious corruption in politics or a police force.

Whilst phone and computer hacking are both clearly illegal (I'm yet to decide how I'd feel if a very serious high-level corruption scandal was unearthed using such techniques) I certainly wouldn't be worried if journalists or private investigators tailed contacts in public, or used covert recording, in pursuit of a story of genuine public interest.

However we're not talking about investigating high level corruption; we're talking about singers, writers, footballers and comedians.

Whilst many of the press methods and practices used to keep tabs on celebrities are not illegal, they are clearly unethical and anti-social when applied indiscriminately in search of dirt on, or to deliberately blacken the name of, someone in the public eye.


Forgetting for a moment about the clearly illegal behaviour, the conundrum of press regulation is to keep press behaviour towards the green end of the spectrum without unduly shackling the press.

And, if the press do need shackling, how to we prevent the manacles of regulation being abused by state or corporate interests to hide stories of legitimate public concern?

Essentially, who will be the arbiters of public interest?

This question of how to regulate is irrelevant if we can work out why the Social Contract failed.  Why did it take so long for any other organisation or institution pick up on the antisocial behaviour of the tabloid press and allow public contempt and market forces to act together to moderate it, thereby working to keep the behaviour of the press in the green zone of the Harm Spectrum?

Note: the press abuses scandal was, eventually, uncovered by sections of the press.

Thursday, 24 November 2011

Abigail Harrison joins the Open Digital Policy Advisory Council

Abigail Harrison,
Managing Director, thebluedoor
I'm extremely pleased to welcome Abigail Harrison to the Open Digital Policy Advisory Council.   Our Advisory Council guides all our policy work at Open Digital.  Abigail brings a wealth of understanding of digital marketing and public relations, augmenting our existing policy team.

She has worked in PR and social media for 18 years, working for some of the biggest agencies, delivering award winning results for leading global brands.

As one of the key players in the digital and social media sector, Abigail founded DigitalSurrey, which regularly draws stand-out sector speakers from global technology and media firms such as Google, IBM, CSC, Ogilvy, Microsoft and the BBC, selling-out every month (although, in the spirit of open knowledge sharing, all events are free to attend).

Abigail has been involved in the organisation of major social media events such as Twestival, TweetCamp and Social Media Week, all of which attract some of the leading movers and shakers in the global social media sector and has also been nominated as the Institute of Directors' South East Director of the year, 2011.






Friday, 4 November 2011

The US regulatory view: ODPO gets lunch with FCC Commissioner Robert McDowell

It was a surprise for a fledgling policy group to get an invite to lunch with a senior US regulator.

The Federal Communications Commission is the US version of Ofcom - on steroids! There are over 1,500 television stations, compared to the UK's handful, plus a host of radio, telephony and data services.  Spectrum allocation and competition questions arising from spectral scarcity (there isn't enough resource to meet the market demand, and the resource available needs to be carefully managed) form a big part of the FCC's job.

Oh, and they regulate taste and decency on broadcast TV channels.
"Most US residents think of the 38th Super Bowl when you mention the FCC, but dealing with incidents like Janet Jackson's wardrobe malfunction is such a small part of my job it's hardly worth a mention."
Commissioner McDowell's approach to regulation seems firmly aligned with our view at Open Digital: regulation is blunt and costly, always has unintended consequences, and should only be enacted when evidence of consumer harm or market abuse can be established.

We joined Big Brother Watch, Policy Exchange, COADEC and representatives from the Tax Payers Alliance for a 2-hour discussion over lunch, where the Commissioner asked as many questions about EU and UK communications policy as we did about US policy.

Although not strictly in the FCC remit, privacy and the EU "cookie directive" featured prominently, with most participants hailing the law which forces all websites using cookies to request permission to store cookie data as misguided and a somewhat extreme example of regulate first, ask for market evidence later.

"Usually the market sorts itself out," said McDowell, referring to a separate problem - one of market dominance in the telecommunications sector, exemplified by Apple and the early exclusive contracts when the iPhone first launched.

Friday, 28 October 2011

We don't need *a* Public Data Corporation, we need a plurality of competing Public Data Corporations

Yesterday we submitted evidence (pdf) to the Government's consultation Data Policy for a Public Data Corporation.

Update 15-Dec-11: We welcome the government's announcement today at an RSA/2020 open data round table where Cabinet Office Minister Frances Maude said "we're moving away from a model where government tries to gain in the short term by extracting value from public data, and moving towards long term benefits [to the UK economy]."  Open Digital understands the plans for a Public Data Corporation have been replaced with a Public Data Office, and it's not just a change in name.

Although the Cabinet Office consultation asked some specific questions about its policy of creating a Public Data Corporation - a central agency to facilitate release of public data sets - including questions about what services the corporation should be allowed to charge for, I decided to argue for not one Public Data Corporation but a plurality of competing Public Data Corporations.

The idea from government seems to be (phase 1) create a Public Data Corporation; (phase 3) profit.  The government seems to think direct returns can be made either by floating the Public Data Corporation and/or charging for access to certain data sets and passing-on some of the charges to the originating departments.

Our submission outlines many of the secondary benefits to free and open public data.  It will keep the barrier to data innovation low; tinkervation - tinkering with data sets despite there being no apparent business model to do so, will only happen if data is free and open.  The UK economy will benefit if UK businesses profit from open data, and the public will still benefit through a range social, democratic and educational uses of data in cases where no taxable revenue is created.

I then argue that the idea behind an investment-led approach to public data is flawed, mainly because we don't know enough about (a) how much of the data held will be used - that's the job of data innovators; and, (b) how online content will be funded in future. The online ad sector is booming, with stacks of cash being spent, but this isn't - as yet - trickling down to online publishers.