Tuesday, 4 October 2011

UK's delayed deployment of 4G fast mobile data to cost UK businesses £732m per year

Our first paper released today (pdf) shows British businesses will lose hundreds of millions of pounds a year because of the UK government’s delay in rolling out fast 4G mobile broadband.

With faster mobile data downloads, more than 37 million business hours a year could be saved. Those extra hours cost UK businesses £732 million a year.

Other countries, including the US, Germany, Sweden, Finland and Korea have already launched 4G fast mobile broadband, putting UK businesses at a commercial and technological disadvantage.

“Visitors to Britain will first notice London’s lack of 4G mobile data when they arrive for the Olympics next year,” says James Firth, report co-author and CEO of Open Digital. "In addition to the lost time through slow mobile data, UK businesses won’t be able to fully benefit from new cloud-based business tools until the UK has a nationwide reliable high speed mobile data network."

Ofcom, the UK regulatory authority tasked with allocating the necessary radio spectrum, does not anticipate the first commercial 4G services to come online before 2013, and nationwide roll-out won’t be complete before 2017.

Open Digital is calling on Ofcom to adopt more ambitious roll-out targets and for the government to acknowledge the massive benefit to the economy from 4G mobile data.

Our findings also put the cost to the UK economy from the recently announced delay of 3-6 months in holding the auction to allocate licenses necessary to run 4G services at £183m - £366m.

Thursday, 29 September 2011

Autonomy as a measure for societal harm from online behaviours

Debates about internet governance are not sustainable at the current level.  All too often we hear three sides of an argument, but are left with no rational framework to evaluate the relative merits of each point of view.

Invariably the viewpoints offered are:
  • Regulation is needed
  • Regulation is not needed
  • In an ideal world we should regulate, but the nature of the internet makes regulation impossible/impracticable
Whether the topic is privacy, free speech, protection of intellectual property rights, national security or freedom from oppression; assertions driven by fear or self interest rise to prominence above evidential findings or deep and thorough rational thinking.

And by fear I'm not just talking about those who fear harm (personal, economic or national) may come through an open internet, but also those who fear the positive power of the internet will be ruined if regulation is enforced.

But can we even start to propose a model, a rational approach, to assessing harm, risk and benefit of digital technology and various regulatory approaches in such a complex domain?

Can we quantify harm from loss of privacy and balance against the benefits brought by linked and accessible data? Or set the perceived risks to political discourse from blocking and censorship against the perceived benefit from limiting access to harmful content?

Your first instinct may be to say "no!"  But if we don't explore new ways of understanding the problem domain we risk stalemate; debates lead by human instinct - great for so many of life's problems, but wholly inadequate for some complex, chaotic social problems when the answer sometimes proves to be counter-intuitive.

Wednesday, 28 September 2011

Eric Joyce MP appointed president of the Open Digital Policy Advisory Council

Open Digital PAC President,
Eric Joyce MP
We're extremely pleased to announce the formation of the Open Digital Policy Advisory Council with one of Parliament's most engaged digital policy specialists, Eric Joyce MP, as President of our advisory body.

Eric has been active on digital issues since his appointment to parliament in 2005, chairing the Digital Economy All Party Parliamentary Group before its recent merger with another parliamentary group. Eric is now the Digital Chair of the Parliament Internet, Communications and Technology Forum (PICTFOR) and he also sits on the All Party Privacy and Injunctions Parliamentary Committee, where he advises on social media.

Also appointed to the Council are Andrew Sharpe, an accomplished media lawyer, who will serve as our general counsel; and Dominique Lazanski, an internet industry expert with a keen focus on civil rights, who will act as our consumer representative.

Eric, Dominique and Andrew join our Open Digital CEO James Firth and Chairman Julian Ranger at Open Digital.  For full details and bios see here.

We're still on the look out for a research advisor with academic or professional research experience to get involved.  If you're interested, get in touch: contact@opendigital.org

There are also a limited number of sponsorship opportunities to help our Open Digital mission.  

Our aim is to build a self-funding, transparent and open organisation for the formation of digital policy; with the aim of promoting an open internet where market competition is fierce but fair, and the consumer voice is strong enough to ensure all our interests (privacy and other freedoms) are maintained. For more details see our charter.

We aim to fund our free-to-access analysis and research with an arms length consultancy, but to get there we need funding.  

Donor-stakeholders can purchase shares in Open Digital Policy Organisation Ltd.  All shareholders over a threshold 2.5% also get to vote on policy positions. We aim to provide a return on investment by growing the company into a self-funding organisation, but we acknowledge our business model is unproven,  therefore we offer a chance to help shape digital policy as an incentive, a donation that may well also yield returns.

There are also opportunities to commission or sponsor analysis and research.  We pledge to release all our work for free, under a Creative Commons license, as we believe in transparency for those attempting to influence government policy; however public release of commissioned research will be delayed by up to 12 months, giving your organisation exclusive access for a limited time.

From time to time some of our research may hit the headlines. There are opportunities to sponsor a paper and have your name associated with the paper and associated press release.

For more information please call 01252 560 426 or email contact@opendigital.org


Tuesday, 23 August 2011

CONSENT Project: research into online privacy and consent

If you have 15 minutes spare, a researcher from Queen's University would welcome input from readers of this blog as part of the CONSENT project - an EU-funded research project on social networking and information gathering.

To start the questionnaire, click here.

The project will look at the use of personal information, privacy, and giving consent online across Europe, and the findings will be made available to European policy makers and legal experts aimed at encouraging the strengthening of the legal protection of consumers and online users.

Whilst Open Digital generally views legislation as a solution of last resort, preferring instead to focus on consumer education of privacy risks in order to harness consumer-brand trust as a driver for improving corporate responsibility towards personal data, we welcome all research in this important area.

@JamesFirth

Tuesday, 26 July 2011

Will social media background checks be the catalyst for a consumer privacy backlash?

Studies show an overwhelming majority of people are ‘concerned’ about their online privacy [see here (pdf), and here], yet when I talk to technology companies large and small they tell me privacy awareness amongst the general public is patchy at best.

As social media background checks start to result in applicants being rejected for jobs simply because of pictures and comments posted on social websites, could we start to see a crippling privacy backlash that will prevent adoption of useful technology because of public fear and mistrust?

Personal data is a commodity that can be traded for ease of functionality (ie reconnect with old friends, recommendations based on past interests) or for free or discounted services.  Additionally, there's the ability to post views and beliefs in an attempt to influence a wide audience.

There are three equations in play:
privacy vs utility
privacy vs price
privacy vs influence
Anecdotally; and also through adoption rates for social media, and store discount cards which track customers' every purchase; in the UK at least we're a nation happy to trade privacy for utility and price.

Or are we? When I talk to family and friends about blogging - an unmistakably public activity - under my real name; many are surprised, and some offer me hushed advice to be careful.

Friday, 8 July 2011

Open Digital's response to the 2nd BSkyB takeover consultation


The Open Digital Policy Organisation Limited,
Reeds Industrial Park
Reeds Road
Frensham
Surrey GU10 3BP


8th July 2011


Dear Secretary of State,

The Open Digital Policy Organisation reiterates the view of its CEO, James Firth, submitted to the first consultation on the 17th March 2011, and reproduced in full here: http://ejf.me/dB

In summary, issues of media plurality in the digital age cannot be considered without looking also at the internet; and, in particular, the privileged position an internet service provider (ISP) like Sky Broadband, owned and operated by BSkyB, holds in its ability to sway - or even restrict - the choice of online news sources available to its subscribers.

Such distortion can come through cross-promotion or price bundling of subscription news services, such as News International's Times Online service, with BSkyB services.  This may or may not unfairly distort the market for other online news providers, and we believe the proper way to assess this concern is for a full competition inquiry.

Distortion could also come through restrictive practices that break principles of so-called network neutrality - but Open Digital Policy believe this issue needs to be addressed separately; in a way that best ensures all ISPs see the market benefit of offering an open internet, and are prevented by law from employing anti-competitive practices in the management of their networks.

We also re-iterate James' concern about potential to distort the market for advertising crucial in supporting news organisations, and therefore critical to the plurality of the press in the UK. With a potential for bundled print, TV and internet advertising deals; again, we believe a Competition Commission inquiry would be the proper place to assess any impact on other news outlets should BSkyB and News International be in a combined position to offer cross-channel advertising deals.

James Firth

CEO, and on behalf of, Open Digital Policy Organisation Limited

Friday, 1 July 2011

John Stuart Mill and liberty, regulation and protection of privacy

In a talk in London on 29 July, Eric Schmidt, Executive Chairman of Google, argued against over-regulation. His premise was that yes the advancements that technology brings can bring with it, in the first flush of that technology, problems; however, those problems that public opinion finds important will most often be solved by technology or by a procedural response to it. In other words give time for the system to self-correct - and presumably only if self-correction does not come (especially after some heavy hinting from opinion and also authority) then regulate.

We must accept that defining what aspects of the web and the Internet to regulate by law and what to regulate by self regulation guided by opinion (on the basis that if you do harm to the customer as a business, eventually the customer will do harm to you) is a very difficult conundrum. What seems clear is that over-regulation is not the answer - but what is over- regulation you may ask?

Eric illustrated his point with a simple example: when telephones became commonplace there was a concern from users that switchboard operators could over-hear conversations and intrude on privacy. Of course they could, and it may well have been a reaction to impose laws on this and in so doing limit what actions could then be taken to replace/improve switchboard operation. Instead no laws were created and relatively shortly the electrical switch was invented which solved the problem without the need for new laws.

I am concerned with the issue of privacy with respect to the web - particularly the self-harm that can be incurred by over-sharing using sites and services which appear private, but are not so - see Clarity in Internet Privacy. However, I am also concerned that legislation in this area, particularly different legislation in different jurisdictions, will not help and will in fact hinder as the world wide web effectively becomes fragmented, and the positive benefits of the web get inhibited. Furthermore, undoubtedly legislation that is rushed may well inhibit further beneficial innovation.

It is important therefore to try and improve privacy through exercise of self control guided by public opinion, and through the application of new technology, and give time for this to occur, before rushing to consider legislation.

The well known philosopher John Stuart Mill summed up this issue well in his essay On Liberty:
"All that makes existence valuable to any one, depends on the enforcement of restraints upon the actions of other people. Some rules of conduct, therefore, must be imposed, by law in the first place, and by opinion on many things which are not fit subjects for the operation of law. 
What these rules should be, is the principal question in human affairs; but if we except a few of the most obvious cases, it is one of those which least progress has been made in resolving. 
No two ages, and scarcely any two countries, have decided it alike; and the decision of one age or country is a wonder to another."
Mill goes on to conclude:
"That principle is, that the sole end for which mankind are warranted, individually or collectively in interfering with the liberty of action of any of their number, is self-protection. That the only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilised community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others."
On the basis that the most egregious of privacy ills today is self-harm, it seems to be that awareness is our first step, followed by self-regulation, not governmental regulation.